CORONER’S REPORT INTO MUSICK POINT BOATING TRAGEDY REINFORCES CRITICAL SAFETY MESSAGES

Source: Coastguard Tautiaki Moana and Water Safety New Zealand

The death of 51-year-old Tēvita Moeakiola is a serious reminder of the need to wear a lifejacket, carry waterproof communication devices, and be well-prepared before heading out on the water.

Mr Moeakiola, a fisherman from Manurewa, drowned after his boat capsized near Musick Point in June 2022. The Coroner found he was not wearing a lifejacket and had no waterproof means of communication.

Mr Moeakiola and two companions had launched from Half Moon Bay Marina for a planned fishing trip near Motuihe Island. While there were lifejackets on board, a Facebook Live video posted earlier that day showed none of the men wearing them.

As the trio returned, the boat took on water and capsized in rough seas. Two men made it to shore – Mr Moeakiola did not survive. His body was recovered the following day.

The Coroner determined the cause of death was drowning, with hypothermia likely a contributing factor. The report highlighted several missed safety steps – including the absence of lifejackets being worn and a lack of waterproof communication equipment – that could have altered the outcome.

“Too many of our men – often experienced, capable, confident – are still heading out not wearing lifejackets. We are not invincible. The water is not to be underestimated, and the conditions can take hold fast. Mr Moeakiola was a father, a husband, out fishing for kai with friends. But, he didn’t make it home” says Rob Hewitt, Water Safety New Zealand spokesperson and ex-Navy diver who miraculously survived 75 hours adrift at sea himself. “Wearing a lifejacket is the simplest and most effective way to reduce drowning fatalities in New Zealand – it’s time to get real about that”.

Water Safety New Zealand data shows that over the last 10 years, more than 76% of boating related drowning victims were not wearing life jackets and the majority were adult men fishing from small craft.

New Zealand’s Boating Safety Code urges all boaties to:

  • Always wear a properly fitted lifejacket.
  • Take two waterproof ways to call for help
  • Check the marine weather forecast
  • Avoid alcohol when boating
  • Be a responsible skipper.

Coastguard Tautiaki Moana says early communication and preparation are critical – and agrees – wearing a lifejacket remains the single most important factor in survival.

“Our thoughts are with Mr Moeakiola’s whānau and friends, sadly, this is one of many tragedies where loved ones haven’t made it home from what should have been a fun day on the water,” says Coastguard Tautiaki Moana CEO Carl McOnie “It’s a heartbreaking reminder of how quickly things can change. Wearing a lifejacket is the single most important thing you can do to make it home safely – it gives you flotation, warmth, and time when you need it most.”

Boaties are encouraged to share their plans before heading out – either by telling a person on shore when and where they’re going, or by logging a Trip Report with Coastguard. “This is easily done by calling *500 on a mobile phone, through our Coastguard App or using a VHF radio. We encourage all New Zealanders to do this this summer before heading out.”

As summer approaches, Coastguard Tautiaki Moana and Water Safety New Zealand are calling on all recreational fishers and boaties to take extra care before heading out.

“Every one of these tragedies has a ripple effect through families and communities,” says Rob. “The lessons are simple – wear your lifejacket, take working waterproof communication, and make sure someone knows where you’re going and when you’ll be back.”

Under the Auckland Navigational Bylaw 2021, lifejacket use on vessels under 6 metres is compulsory – unless the skipper gives permission not to wear one. A working group including Coastguard Tautiaki Moana and Water Safety New Zealand presented to Auckland Council’s Safety Regulatory Committee last month with a united call for change to that current bylaw.  

Says Rob, “The bylaw assumes skippers have a realistic view of their own boating competency and can make sound safety decisions for themselves and their passengers. The data, and this report, tells a different story.”

Notes: A Trip Report is a record of boaties’ trip details and used to assist search and rescue only if the person is reported overdue. Trip Reports are not actively monitored (unless it’s a bar crossing trip report). Coastguard can receive thousands in a single day over summer, so it’s vital that someone on shore knows the plans of those heading out and can raise the alarm if they don’t return as expected.

Sent on behalf of Coastguard Tautiaki Moana and Water Safety New Zealand by These Guys I Know.

Local Elections – Porirua City Elections 2025 – Preliminary results

Source: Porirua City Council

Preliminary results in the Porirua City local body elections are now available, including all votes cast other than special votes.
This year there were 797 special votes.
These results update the progress results released on Saturday, including the previously uncounted 2844 votes cast between midday Friday and midday Saturday.
Based on the preliminary results, current Mayor Anita Baker has been re-elected receiving 8708 votes. Kathleen Filo finished second, with 7744 votes, followed by Ura Wilson-Pokoati with 1493 votes.
Elected in the Onepoto General Ward are Kathleen Filo (1625 votes), Geoff Hayward (1301 votes), Mike Duncan (1226 votes), Izzy Ford (1178 votes) and Hemi Fermanis (1109 votes).
In the Pāuatahanui General Ward the successful candidates are Josh Trlin (1723 votes), Nathan Waddle (1636 votes), Ross Leggett (1549 votes), and Moira Lawler (1536 votes).
In the Parirua Māori Ward, Kylie Wihapi has received 895 votes, ahead of Jess Te Huia on 868 votes, Raniera Albert on 304 votes, and Rawinia Rimene on 198 votes.
Voters have opted to keep the Māori Ward. There were 11,372 votes to keep and 5127 to remove.
In the non-binding poll, voters were in favour of working with other councils in the Wellington region to explore the possibility of creating one single council (9324 for and 7145 against).
Final results will be released once the 797 special votes are counted and these are expected on Thursday 16 October, though this may change.
For more details of the preliminary results visit poriruacity.govt.nz/elections

Legal Issues – PSNA legal challenge to NZ Superfund’s investments opens in Auckland High Court tomorrow morning (Tuesday 14th October)

Source: Palestinian Solidarity Network Aotearoa (PSNA)

 

The Palestine Solidarity Network’s legal challenge against the New Zealand Superfund’s investments in companies helping to build and maintain illegal Israeli settlements in the occupied Palestinian Territories opens in the Auckland High Court tomorrow (Tuesday 14 October) and is expected to run for two days.

 

The named plaintiffs are PSNA Co-Chairs, Maher Nazzal and John Minto, and Rawaa Elhanafy.  The lawyers taking the case are Rodney Harrison KC and Frances Joychild KC.

 

Mahar Nazzal says the Superfund has investments in companies identified by the United Nations Human Rights Council as providing services and utilities supporting the maintenance and existence of illegal settlements on Palestinian land in the Occupied Palestinian Territory.

 

The UN list was updated on 26 September 2025 and the updated database is here in a pdf.

 

Nazzal says the recent report by Special Rapporteur for the occupied Palestinian Territories, Francesca Albanese From Economy of Occupation to Economy of Genocide’ says when Israel is committing genocide in Gaza many companies such Booking.Com and AirBnB are profiting from “occupation tourism” in Palestine.

 

“We look forward to the court having a thorough look at the Superfund’s investments and whether they are in line with their legal obligations” 

 

John Minto

Maher Nazzal

Co-Chairs

Palestine Solidarity Network Aotearoa

 

Case Summary

The New Zealand Superfund has investments in four companies listed in June 2023 by the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights.

 

  • AirBnB
  • Booking.com
  • Motorola
  • Alstrom 

 

Each of these companies is deeply embedded in Israel’s illegal occupation. AirBnB and Booking.com are advertising homes for rent in illegal Israeli settlements. This encourages investors to purchase these properties and also encourages the building and expansion of these illegal settlements.

 

Motorola has a long lucrative history of providing technology and infrastructure to enable Israel’s mass surveillance of Palestinians across the Occupied Palestinian Territory as well as involvement in providing transport infrastructure which links the illegal settlements via racially segregated roads.

 

Why does this matter now?

In December 2022, Israel elected arguably its most extreme ethno-nationalist government ever.  It stepped up the brutal repression of Palestinians and made clear it would not countenance a meaningful peace plan or the formation of a Palestinian state.

 

The new government said its “top priority” was to push ahead with more illegal Israeli settlements on occupied Palestinian land.

 

In the last week of June 2023, Israeli ministers announced plans to build more than 5,000 additional houses in these illegal settlements on Palestinian land. Further expansion of these settlements in the Occupied West Bank is taking place while the world is distracted with Israel’s ongoing mass killing and mass starvation of Palestinians in Gaza.

 

This “green light” to illegal Israeli settlers has resulted in a massive wave of settler attacks on Palestinians towns and villages with pogroms against the Palestinian populations – attacks which have been actively supported and assisted by the Israeli Defence Forces.

 

A very recent case was the killing of Awdah Hathaleen who was involved in the production of the Oscar Award winning documentary ‘No Other Land’.

 

Within the last two weeks Israel’s Minister of Finance Bezalel Smotrich has approved plans for another illegal Israeli settlement which would split occupied East Jerusalem from the occupied West Bank – a move his office said would “bury” the idea of a Palestinian state.

 

The case has taken on renewed urgency with the July 2024 Advisory Opinion of the International Court of Justice, which found Israel’s occupation of the land it captured in the 1967 Six-day War is illegal and urged signatory countries to withdraw all “aid or assistance” to Israel in maintaining its illegal occupation.

 

On 18 September 2024 the United Nations General Assembly voted in support of the ICJ ruling (New Zealand supported the resolution) which includes the demand:

 

(c) To implement sanctions, including travel bans and asset freezes, against natural and legal persons engaged in the maintenance of Israel’s unlawful presence in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including in relation to settler violence;

 

A further United Nations General Assembly resolution (Peaceful settlement of the question of Palestine) was passed in November 2024 which also called for states

 

“Not to render aid or assistance to illegal settlement activities”.

Retail – FreshChoice and Everyday Rewards team up for unbeatable value!

Source: FreshChoice

From 20 October, FreshChoice is leveling up the shopping experience, enabling customers to earn and use their Everyday Rewards points at all FreshChoice supermarkets.

FreshChoice Executive General Manager Tim Cartwright says New Zealand customers see value in the Everyday Rewards programme and FreshChoice is excited to offer this to customers for the first time.

“The ability to earn points and rewards is one of the top three reasons New Zealanders choose where to shop. In the current environment, customers are increasingly looking for value and we see the Everyday Rewards programme as an important offering.

“We are always looking for ways to enhance our customer offering and deliver excellent customer experiences and our local owner-operators and teams have worked hard to deliver this initiative before the busy holiday trading period.”

Everyday Rewards launched in New Zealand in February 2024 and has been growing ever since, with a wide range of partners including: Woolworths, bp, g.a.s., ASB, Airpoints, Qantas Frequent Flyer, Petstock, and MILKRUN.

Everyday Reward Head of Loyalty Stephanie Welch says it has been a successful first year for Everyday Rewards.

“Our focus has been on delivering value back to our members, partners, and suppliers and we're absolutely thrilled to now offer Everyday Rewards in FreshChoice supermarkets.

“Everyday Rewards has experienced steady growth, attracting both new members and partners to the programme. We’re committed to building on this success and we’re pleased that FreshChoice customers will now have the opportunity to earn points and rewards.”

Further details about Everyday Rewards can be found at everydayrewards.co.nz

About FreshChoice

FreshChoice is a leading supermarket brand in New Zealand, dedicated to providing fresh, high-quality products tailored to the needs of local communities. Focusing on supporting local suppliers and employing local residents, FreshChoice is committed to enhancing the shopping experience for customers. FreshChoice is currently undertaking a brand expansion with SuperValue stores being converted to FreshChoice.

Science and Climate – Discovery of Antarctic methane skyrockets

Source: Earth Sciences New Zealand

New methane seeps are being discovered at an astonishing rate in Antarctic waters.
Methane is a greenhouse gas, so scientists are investigating how these sources of methane may be connected to our warming climate.
Earth Sciences New Zealand marine scientist Dr Sarah Seabrook says these seeps are recently formed, indicating a fundamental shift in regional methane release around the continent.
“Methane seeps are areas of the seafloor where methane and other chemicals escape from reservoirs underneath the seabed and dissolve in the water, often having streams of bubbles that extend all the way up to the surface.
“The first was discovered by chance in 2012 and since then they’ve been cropping up at a remarkable rate. A similar phenomenon has also been observed in the Arctic,” said Dr Seabrook. 
Dr Seabrook leads the latest research on these seeps, published this month in Nature Communications, which explores the emergence and discovery of dozens of them in the shallow coastal environment of Antarctica.
“Every time we discover or hear of a new one, we feel immediate excitement, but that excitement is quickly replaced with anxiety and concern about what it all means. If they follow the behaviour of other global seep systems, there is the potential for rapid transfer of methane to the atmosphere from a source that is not currently factored into future climate change scenarios,” said Dr Seabrook. 
The Earth Sciences NZ team have been using remotely operated vehicles and divers under the ice to search for new seeps, sampling sites ranging from approximately five to 240 meters deep.
“Last year, we went to Cape Evans to look at one small area where gas bubbles had been discovered and were hoping to find that one site still bubbling. Instead, we found dozens more. If these seeps keep emerging at the areas we are working in, it really begs the question of what the shallow coastal environment of Antarctica may look like five or 10 years from now. This system is rapidly changing before our eyes from one year to the next.”
Dr Seabrook and her team will be returning this season to investigate more seep sites. However, some areas from last season such as Cape Evans are inaccessible because of disappearing sea ice. 
This work is funded by a Royal Society of New Zealand Marsden Grant and the Antarctic Science Platform.

Northland News – Four new councillors for Northland Regional Council

Source: Northland Regional Council

Voters have delivered four new councillors to the nine-strong Northland Regional Council – and voted to remove the council’s Te Raki Māori Constituency.
Council CEO Jonathan Gibbard says based on preliminary results, the new councillors are Colin (Toss) Kitchen (who will represent the Bay of Islands-Whangaroa General Constituency and who is returning to council after a three-year break), John Hunt (Coastal South General Constituency) and Pita Tipene and Arama Morunga (both Te Raki Māori Constituency).
Re-elected to council are Amy Macdonald (Coastal Central General Constituency), Joe Carr (Far North General Constituency), John Blackwell (Kaipara General Constituency), Jack Craw (Whangārei Central General Constituency) and Geoff Crawford, who was re-elected unopposed in the Mid North General Constituency.
Mr Gibbard thanked all those who stood for council and congratulated those who were successful.
He says a joint powhiri for all four new Northland councils is expected to be held at Waitangi on Thursday 23 October. Barring any calls for a vote recount, Northland Regional Council’s inaugural meeting will be held from 10am on Thursday 30 October.
Mr Gibbard says one of the first orders of business for the new regional council will be the swearing in of councillors, then selection of council’s new chair and their deputy.
Commenting on voters’ decision to remove the council’s Te Raki Māori constituency, Mr Gibbard says the outcome of the poll means that while council still have its two Māori seats for the next three years, they’ll be disestablished for the 2028 elections.
(On the preliminary figures, 30,967 people voted to remove the two Te Raki Māori seats, while 29,589 voted to keep them.)
“Our priority now is to support all our newly elected council members as they settle into their roles, so we can continue to lead the important mahi we’re here to do – for our environment and for the people of Te Taitokerau.”
The preliminary results are:
Bay of Islands-Whangaroa General Constituency (one vacancy):
Colin (Toss) Kitchen (elected) 1936 votes; Lane Ayr 1333; Jane Wright 1240; Murray Hosking 1226; Nyze Manuel 959; Karl Barkley 665.
Coastal Central General Constituency (one vacancy):
Amy Macdonald (elected) 4350; Greg Chalmers 2824.
Coastal South General Constituency (one vacancy):
John Hunt (elected) 3148; Rick Stolwerk 2615; Robert Goodhue 1627.
Far North General Constituency (one vacancy):
Joe Carr (elected) 3590; Marty Yuretich 1976; Reina Tuai Penney 1217.
Kaipara General Constituency (one vacancy):
John Blackwell (elected) 5508; Lorraine (Nossi) Norris 1743.
Mid North General Constituency (one vacancy):
Geoff Crawford; elected unopposed.
Te Raki Māori Constituency (two vacancies):
Pita Tipene (elected) 6113; Arama Morunga (elected) 4933; Peter-Lucas Jones 3642; Tui Shortland 3446.
Whangarei Central General Constituency (one vacancy):
Jack Craw (elected) 2920; Caroline Davis 2687.
Mr Gibbard says the official result is expected to be declared on Friday 17 October.
“These will be issued via public notice and uploaded once all special votes have been validated by the Electoral Commission.”
At this stage, overall voting turnout was 47.7% percent of eligible voters. That compared to 43.2% in 2022.
Election results are available from: www.nrc.govt.nz/results2025

Aged Care – New report finds broken aged care sector harming our elderly – NZNO

Source: New Zealand Nurses Organisation

A new research report which interviewed 80 nurses and health care assistants in the aged care sector reveals the disturbing impact on our elderly of an under-staffed and under-funded sector, Tōpūtanga Tapuhi Kaitiaki o Aotearoa NZNO says.
The NZNO report Care in Crisis: Manaaki i te Raru also surveyed 415 aged care workers and analysed 156 health and safety issues related to unsafe staffing. It is being launched formally in Wellington on Wednesday (15 October).
NZNO Age Safe committee co-chair and health care assistant (kaiāwhina) Brianna Dynes says residents are missing out on the most basic care because there isn’t enough staff to go around.
“Nurses and kaiāwhina are constantly forced to make impossible choices about who gets help first because they are stretched so thin.
“Our kaumātua are being harmed by the sector designed to care for them.
“Residents are suffering falls because care givers are unable to give them the support they need. They’re being put in continence products because they don’t have time to toilet them and they have infections because nurses are too busy to change their dressings and facilities are buying cheap wound products, and even cutting them in half, to save money,” Brianna Dynes says.
Fellow NZNO Age Safe committee co-chair Tracey Morgan says Care in Crisis: Manaaki i te Raru is irrefutable evidence of a sector in crisis.
“However, everyday nurses and kaiāwhina show that quality aged care is possible, if they are given the time and the resources they need to do their jobs properly.
“This report doesn’t just highlight the issues facing the sector; it provides a clear, practical plan to reset aged care and provide dignity to residents in the last years of their lives.
“That includes all facilities having a 24/7 nurse on site, legislated and evidence-based care hours that providers are legally required to meet, safe staffing ratios and funding determined on the cost of delivering care.
“The importance of cultural care must also be properly recognised and funded so kaumātua receive care that upholds tikanga and whānau connections. It must also be able to meet the needs of our elderly from other cultural backgrounds,” Tracey Morgan says. 
Figures at a glance:
Care in Crisis: Manaaki i te Raru is based on:
  • 80 in-depth interviews with nurses and health care assistants (kaiāwhina) working in the aged care sector from Kaitaia to Bluff.
  • Surveys of 415 aged care nurses and kaiāwhina.
  • Analysis of 156 health and safety forms related to unsafe staffing.
  • 53.4% of nurses and kaiāwhina surveyed reported their shifts were understaffed often or most of the time.
  • 87% strongly agreed staffing levels have affected their ability to provide high-quality care.
  • 43.9% felt they didn’t have enough time to do everything required most days with just 5.8% saying they always had sufficient time.
  • 39.8% reported frequently thinking about leaving the sector.
  • Kaiāwhina report residents are going without showers, getting their meals late or cold and getting no help with toileting 25.2% of all shifts. 
Selection of health care worker quotes:
Interview participants have been given pseudonyms to protect their identity, but all other info provided such as their role, workplace and region) is accurate.
  • “The quality of care is always correlated to the time that the staff can give to them.” – Laura, Clinical Nurse Manager, Enliven
  • “Some days it honestly feels like a milking shed, you know, line them up, hose them down.” – Tina, Kaiāwhina, Summerset, Central
  • “Some residents don’t get fed at all.” – Logan, Kaiāwhina, Bupa, Central
  • “Underarms didn’t get washed… teeth and dentures… missed more often than not.” – Ava, Kaiāwhina, Presbyterian Support Services, Te Waipounamu
  • “Three out of five residents do not need incontinence products.” – Rebecca, Clinical Nurse Manager, Arvida
  • “We started getting really budget dressings that would disintegrate into the wound.” – Sarah, Clinical Nurse Manager, Arvida
  • “Sadly, I know people don’t get turned… the evidence is on the residents.” – Grace, Unit Coordinator, Bupa, Te Manawa Taki
  • “Recently one of our dementia-level residents swallowed a glove.” – Jenna, RN, Bupa, Te Waipounamu
  • “The incidence of residents having falls has increased massively…” – Jacki, Kaiāwhina, small not-for-profit, Wellington
  • “Everything in te ao Māori world is missing in aged care.” – V, Māori Kaiāwhina, Heritage
  • “They honour that time of the resident’s life, but not the present.” – Māori kaimahi
  • “We’ll put ourselves second… they’re paramount.” – Theresa, RN, NZ Aged Care Services
  • “I feel I did my best to support them, but I feel ashamed.” – Jenna, RN, Bupa, Te Waipounamu
  • “We’re let down by everybody everywhere.” – Bonnie, Nurse Practitioner, Oceania.

Advocacy – Welcoming home the best of New Zealand – Will Alexander – Christchurch Airport 2.45pm today – PSNA

Source: Palestinian Solidarity Network Aotearoa

Palestine solidarity supporters will be welcoming home Will Alexander this afternoon at 2.45pm at Christchurch airport. Will and his partner Ava Mulla were part of the latest flotilla to try to break the Israeli siege of Gaza.

Will and Ava were aboard the “Conscience” which, along with eight smaller boats, was illegally intercepted by Israel on Wednesday last week in international waters while on its way to deliver desperately needed humanitarian aid to Gaza.

The New Zealand government has not protested this seizure of New Zealand citizens in international waters.

Will and Ava were taken to the “terrorist” prison of Ketziot and with the others were subjected to harsh detention conditions and degrading treatment until flown to Istanbul, Turkiye. Will is flying on to New Zealand and Ava to Germany. 

Will and Ava represent the best of New Zealand values of compassion and caring and being prepared to uphold those values for all human beings. Our government represents something else.

We invite media representatives to report on Will’s mission and his welcome home.

John Minto
Co-Chair PSNA

Civil Defence – Prioritising prevention: Building a resilient New Zealand

Source: National Emergency Management Agency (NEMA)

 

Key government and private sector organisations are calling for stronger action to reduce risk before disaster strikes.

 

Marking the International Day for Disaster Risk Reduction, the National Emergency Management Agency (NEMA), the Natural Hazards Commission Toka Tū Ake (NHC), and the Insurance Council of New Zealand | Te Kāhui Inihua o Aotearoa (ICNZ) are urging more coordinated resilience-building to help protect people, property and communities across Aotearoa.

 

“On a personal level, it’s crucial to build your own resilience first, and that of your whānau and community,” John Price, NEMA’s Director of Civil Defence Emergency Management says.

 

“If we invest in our resilience now, we’ll be more prepared when we’re tested later.”

 

NHC invests in resilience projects that reduce natural hazard impacts through research, education, and information and advice on risk reduction.

“In a country at high risk of natural hazards, it is important that we all make evidence-based decisions for safer buildings and land use planning,” says Tina Mitchell, Chief Executive of NHC.

 

NHC also works to ensure high-quality data on natural hazards is available to decision-makers.

 

“A key priority for NHC is establishing a national view of risk so it guides resilience efforts in all its forms,” Tina Mitchell says.

 

ICNZ Chief Executive Kris Faafoi says the best time to act is before disaster strikes.

 

“The likelihood of more intense and severe weather events is rising, and New Zealand must prioritise risk reduction to protect communities and maintain insurance accessibility for all Kiwis,” he says.

 

Kris Faafoi is also calling for accelerated progress on New Zealand’s Climate Adaptation Framework and continued cooperation across all sectors to ensure the nation is better prepared for future challenges.

 

“Avoiding high-risk areas and investing in resilient infrastructure isn’t just the right thing to do, it makes economic sense. Research shows every $1 invested in flood risk reduction can save up to $4 in future response and recovery costs.”

 

NEMA, NHC and ICNZ recently signed a partnership to strengthen New Zealand’s disaster resilience through closer collaboration and knowledge sharing.

 

“We have significant expertise available in New Zealand – if we build on existing partnerships and co-ordinate effort, it will take us a long way,” says Tina Mitchell.

 

Mr Price says everyone can play a part.

 

“Get to know your neighbours and people in your community now, so that when an emergency happens, first responders can focus on those who need it most.

 

“Closely knit communities are more resilient because they’re more likely to look out for each other and help rebuild afterwards.”

 

New Zealanders can also take part in ShakeOut, the national earthquake drill, on 16 October. Visit shakeout.govt.nzto sign up and learn how to be better prepared.

Luxon "goes full Trump" with climate-denying methane backdown – Greenpeace

Source: Greenpeace
The Government has confirmed it will rewrite New Zealand’s once bipartisan climate change law to water down methane targets and permanently exclude agriculture from the Emissions Trading Scheme – a move Greenpeace says amounts to full-blown climate denial.
“This is truly astounding,” says Greenpeace Aotearoa climate campaigner, Amanda Larsson. “Luxon has gone full-on Trump. He’s choosing climate denial and corporate profits over our kids’ future.”
The decision will weaken targets for biogenic methane – mostly from livestock – despite strong warnings from climate scientists that doing so could derail the global fight against climate change.
“New Zealand is the world’s biggest dairy exporter. If we back down on cutting emissions from our most polluting industry, you can bet other big livestock-producing countries will jump on the bandwagon. That could be game over for the climate,” says Larsson.
“As if it wasn’t bad enough that people can’t afford butter while Fonterra banks huge profits – now Luxon’s handing big dairy a free pass to keep polluting, at the expense of a liveable future for our kids.
“This is about profits for a few, at the expense of climate catastrophe for millions.”
At the heart of the move to reduce methane targets is a controversial accounting trick called “no additional warming”, designed to justify continued high levels of agricultural methane emissions – even as science shows they must fall fast.
“It’s a political trick dressed up as science,” says Larsson. “It pretends current methane emissions are fine – when in reality, they’re fuelling the climate crisis.”
The decision comes after heavy lobbying from the meat and dairy industries – sectors now directly represented in government, with former Federated Farmers lobbyist Andrew Hoggard holding key ministerial roles. Even today, Federated Farmers’ response to the new methane targets was released before the Government decision was publicly available, highlighting close links between industry lobbyists and Government.
Larsson says, “Luxon might think he’s doing the livestock industry a solid but, really, he is throwing farmers under the bus. Today’s announcement is a signal to our climate-concerned trading partners to start looking elsewhere.”
Earlier this year, dozens of climate scientists wrote an open letter, featured on the front page of the Financial Times, urging Prime Minister Christopher Luxon not to weaken New Zealand’s methane target. They called instead for stronger ambition, in line with advice from the independent Climate Change Commission.
Today’s announcement follows other major climate U-turns – including lifting the offshore oil and gas exploration ban and pledging $200 million in fossil fuel subsidies.
Both moves conflict with international climate law and trade agreements, and could carry legal consequences under the recent International Court of Justice advisory opinion and clauses in New Zealand’s trade deals with the EU and UK.
Notes:
Methane is responsible for nearly a third of today’s global warming. It’s a short-lived but super-potent gas – over 80 times more powerful than CO₂ over 20 years. Slashing methane, particularly from livestock, is seen by scientists as the fastest way to slow warming in our lifetimes – a vital “emergency brake”.