Source: PSA
The PSA is calling for an independent review of the appointment of the new Law Commission President after revelations Hon Judith Collins was appointed without any recruitment process, selection panel or consideration of rival candidates.
“This is a concerning breach of good practice for appointments to independent institutions and we call for an independent review,” said Duane Leo, National Secretary for the Public Service Association Te Pūkenga Here Tikanga Mahi.
“Judith Collins was the only person considered for this role – there was no contestable process, no advertising, no shortlisting. It amounted to a simple Cabinet confirmation.
“This is not a reflection on Judith Collins' credentials, but without a proper process, how can New Zealanders have confidence the best person was appointed?
“There are many highly qualified legal experts who were denied any chance to apply. This is a pivotal role in our legal system – one that brings an independent lens to important legal issues – and it merits a thorough, transparent selection process.
“The irony is stark. Just this week in Parliament, as Public Service Minister Judith Collins spoke about the Public Service Amendment Bill, saying 'This bill reaffirms the principle of merit-based appointments… We're strengthening the Act to make sure that the best person for the job is the one who gets it, not the most familiar or the easiest option but the person with the right skills and experience to deliver.'
“What's good for the goose should be good for the gander. The Government can't lecture public servants about merit-based appointments while ignoring these very principles when rewarding one of its own with a prestigious taxpayer-funded role.
“Cabinet guidelines require such appointments to follow good practice processes set out by the Public Service Commission. Those processes exist to protect against cronyism and ensure public confidence in our institutions.
“We note that Foreign Minister Winston Peters has previously stopped the appointment of former politicians to top diplomatic roles for exactly this reason – to maintain proper standards and avoid the perception of political rewards.
“This appointment sets a worrying precedent. The Law Commission's independence and credibility depend on public confidence that its leadership is above political influence.
“New Zealanders deserve better. They deserve transparency in how senior public roles are filled, and confidence that merit – not political loyalty – determines who gets these positions.”
The Public Service Association Te Pūkenga Here Tikanga Mahi is Aotearoa New Zealand's largest trade union, representing and supporting more than 95,000 workers across central government, state-owned enterprises, local councils, health boards and community groups.